Dorie's Coconut Custard Tart; Photo by The Professor

Musical pairing –  Is This Love, Bob Marley & The Wailers

I have a confession to make . . . well maybe two confessions to make . . . first, I’m going rogue on my Tuesdays With Dorie group this week; this should come as no surprise to those of you who know me as I’ve never been one to run with the crowd . . . that’s just how I roll . . .  But hear me out – it was my birthday weekend and somehow Honey-Wheat Cookies just didn’t seem as celebratory as a Toasted Coconut Custard Tart which brings me to my second confession:  I’m crazy for coconut, I’m crazy for coconut!!!  And yes, that statement deserves triple exclamation points!!!

I’ve had a pretty darn good coconut cream pie recipe for years but when pastry goddess Dorie Greenspan, includes a recipe for a Coconut Custard Tart in her book, I’m thinking that is a recipe worth taking notice – and I was right.  Nestled over a buttery and flaky shortbread-like crust, is a pastry cream that is at once silky, yet firm with the tiniest hint of dark rum; coconut toasted ever so slightly is then folded into the pastry cream.  The whole shebang is topped with real cream, softly whipped with another splash of dark rum, and an additional sprinkling of coconut completes the grand finale – absolute perfection.

Photo by The Professor
Photo by The Professor

It’s worth noting that Dorie clarifies the difference between a pie and a tart, which I must confess, I’ve had trouble defining (and which is why this is one of my all-time favorite cookbooks – I learn sooooo much!).   Pretty simple really, as a tart gives equal billing to all three components:  the crust, the filling and the topping – every bite contains equal amounts of each.  Pies, on the other hand, have more filling, a little less topping and even less crust.  Who knew?  Either way, add a cup of coffee or a vanilla latte’ and, ‘oh-my-goddie-in-heaven’, is that ever divine!!!  Yes, another three exclamation points!!!

Photo by Smith Bites

I’m dreaming of white sandy beaches, waves lapping at my ankles with the tunes of Bob Marley jammin’ in the background . . . sans the bikini . . .

Be sure to subscribe to my feed or follow me on Twitter!


You’ll have to visit Cinemon Girl for the recipe – BUT you’ll have to wait until March 2nd; until then, these pictures will have to suffice!


  1. Barbara – YES! It’s less fattening – LOVE IT! And thanks for stopping by!

  2. Love this dessert! And adore coconut as much as you do. Does the fact that it is a tart make it less fattening because there’s less filling? 😉
    I made a lemon tart this week so when I post it, I’m going to use your quote from Dorie!

  3. Go for it Carol – it is divine but fair warning – you’d better have guests or you’ll end up eating it all yourself!

    Avery – Congrats! You’re the first person to comment about the music – we think it pairs nicely with our food!!

  4. This is beautiful! I love the last picture. I’m also really enjoying the music that goes with each post– nice touch.

  5. I will be making this – have always wanted to get a tart pan and coconut pie’s are my fav – so good excuse!

  6. HAH! What I should have said was, ‘sans the bikini and dressed in a turtleneck from neck to ankles!’ The recipe is really delicious!

  7. sans the bikini? is it a special beach?

    this is going to be teh Easter Dessert for my guys-they are coconut fanatics!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *